A suspicious voicemail tells me to call back or press a key: what to do
Urgent voicemails threatening legal action, account problems or arrest, or giving an unfamiliar callback number, are a standard scam tactic. Don’t call the number in the message; look up the organization’s official number yourself, and protect your voicemail with a strong PIN.
Summarize this article with
Don't call back the number in the message. Scammers leave urgent voicemails precisely so you'll call a number they control. If the message names a real company or agency, find its official number yourself, on your statement, card or its website, and call that instead.
Why do scammers leave voicemails?
To get you to make the call yourself. The FCC's Scam Glossary describes several versions:
- The legal threat. Callers leave voicemails threatening legal action if you don't call back. The FCC's guidance: never call back an unfamiliar number, because it may lead to a scam.
- The international callback. An urgent voicemail gives a callback number with an 809 area code. It looks like a U.S. area code but is actually international, so you're charged international rates while the person answering tries to keep you on the line as long as possible. The FCC links this to the "one ring" scam, in which a single late-night ring from a foreign number tempts you to call back.
- The government or bank story. The FBI says law enforcement and government impersonators primarily contact victims through unsolicited phone calls and often spoof real agency numbers and employee names. AT&T lists an automated voice telling you to return a call, or asking you to call back a number different from the one on caller ID, among its phone scam warning signs.
How can I tell if a voicemail is real?
Compare it with what the agencies themselves say about how they contact people:
- The IRS says that when it uses automated phone messages, they direct you to IRS.gov to manage your account and don't share specific details. A recorded message threatening arrest over taxes isn't how it works.
- Government agencies won't call or text to demand any form of payment or to ask for personal or sensitive information, the FBI says.
- Scam robocalls often claim to be about your Social Security number, taxes or Medicare, according to the FTC.
Should I press a key or call the number?
No. The FTC says pressing numbers to speak to someone or to be removed from a list will probably only lead to more robocalls. The FCC adds that scammers use the "press a button to stop these calls" trick to identify potential targets. Calling an unfamiliar callback number can also cost you money if it's international.
What should I do with the message?
- Don't call back the number in the voicemail or the one it came from.
- Verify independently. Hang up and call the number on your account statement or the organization's official website, as the FCC recommends.
- Write down the details: the number that called, the callback number in the message, and the date and time. Then delete the message.
- Report it. The FTC asks you to report the number that received the call, the caller ID number and any number you were told to call back at DoNotCall.gov, or at ReportFraud.ftc.gov if it was an attempt to get money or information. You can also file a complaint with the FCC.
How do I protect my own voicemail?
Scammers don't just leave voicemails; some break into them.
- Set a strong voicemail PIN. The FCC warns that some voicemail services are preset to allow access when you call from your own number, and a hacker could spoof your number to get in if you haven't set a password.
- Avoid default codes. The FCC describes hackers who guess default passwords like "1234" and change the greeting to accept collect-call charges, then use the phone for international calls.
- Check your voicemail regularly and clear out spam so it doesn't fill up and you don't miss important calls.
Can I keep scam calls from reaching me at all?
You can send calls from unknown numbers straight to voicemail, which makes the advice above even more important. On iPhone, Apple's Screen Unknown Callers setting can ask unknown callers for a reason before your phone rings, or silence them and send them to voicemail. Your carrier may also offer call blocking or labeling: the FCC's robocall guide suggests asking about it.
Before calling any number from a voicemail, you can look it up on NoCall to see whether others have reported it.
Sources and review
Reviewed:
- FCC – Scam Glossary
- FCC – Caller ID Spoofing
- FCC – Stop Unwanted Robocalls and Texts
- FTC – Robocalls
- IRS – How to know it’s really the IRS calling or knocking on your door
- AT&T – Recognize and prevent phone scams
- Apple Support – Manage unknown callers on iPhone
- FBI IC3 – Scammers Impersonating Law Enforcement and Government Officials in Fraud Schemes (PSA, 17 Sep 2026)
Numbering, carrier tools, and reporting procedures can change. Verify sensitive steps with the linked primary authority.
Article details
Editorial content reviewed by NoCall with practical context for spotting suspicious calls and messages.
Received a suspicious call?
Look up the number in NoCall before sharing data, calling back, or clicking any link.
Search a phone number or a company name (Bank of America, Verizon and AT&T...) to check if it has been reported as spam.
Keep investigating
Check who's calling from these community-reported prefixes and directories.

